The Worst Car Insurance Myths Drivers Still Believe

Trying to find cheaper car insurance in the UK can lead people down all sorts of rabbit holes, a lot of them waste your time, are just plain wrong, or can get you into trouble in the long run. From brand loyalty, to where you park, and what your job role is, there are a lot of variables.

  • Keep any details you give insurers true and honest. Lying to insurers gets very messy, very fast.
  • Insurers want to help you, but they need you to be honest, careful, and legally compliant to do so.
  • Keep all your information up to date, old information can get your policy claims denied, not fun.

1. โ€œFully comp means youโ€™re covered for everythingโ€

Fully comprehensive insurance is one of the highest levels of insurance available in the UK, meaning youโ€™re covered for damages to your own car, theft, and fires. BUT.

Fully comp does not always include things such as โ€œDrive Other Carโ€ insurance (youโ€™ll have to check your individual policy for that one) This is often not included on young driver policies, or those with special exclusions. Personal belongings, modifications to your car, and courtesy cars will often always be extra to your policy too, and will have to be added on top. Always check your insurance policy documents!

2. โ€œAdding a parent or older driver is always cheaperโ€

A lot of the time this is true, but not always. If that added driver is from a risky postcode area, and with claims or points, they could push your price up, even if youโ€™re a younger driver.

3. โ€œWhen you buy insurance doesnโ€™t matterโ€

The time your look for, and purchase, insurance policies matters a lot. Last minute purchases can be seen as more impulsive behaviour, and have been sometimes known to raise insurance prices, so plan accordingly, and set your policy start date between 21 and 26 days away.

Some insurance companies account for the time that you look for quotes online too, and midnight searches can seem more risky than midday ones.

4. โ€œThird party insurance is always cheaperโ€

Not the case in this day and age, and you might hear this one a lot. Third party insurance, although it covers far less than comprehensive, is seen as a risky choice these days. Because of this, it can be much more cost effective just to go for Fully Comprehensive insurance in the first place.

5. โ€œParking on the street is always more expensive than drivewaysโ€

This is only the case if youโ€™re not in an area where driveways have a higher risk for theft, otherwise youโ€™re sometimes better off street parked!

Sat in a Mazda MX5 whilst Paynos talks about car insurance

6. โ€œModifications increase your insurance premiumsโ€

This is not always the case, and with specialist insurance companies, they can often accomadate modified cars with responsible owners for very competitive prices.

7. โ€œNamed drivers build their own no claims bonusโ€

Named drivers that are secondarily on a policy will not normally be building an NCB. Only the policy holder will build their no claims bonus, unless specifically offered otherwise on the policy.

8. โ€œBlack box insurance is only for bad driversโ€

Telematics insurance, or โ€œBlack Box Insuranceโ€ can often be a great option for younger drivers, those who do low mileage, and even those who just consider themselves good drivers. If you drive well, you may often get a cheaper premium than you normally might.

9. โ€œLoyalty gets you a better priceโ€

Loyalty might have got you further in the old days, but these days some shopping around for car insurance is required. Comparison sites, going direct, and haggling over the phone are often great ways of reducing your up coming insurance premium.

Here are the latest car insurance statistics from MoneySuperMarket

10. โ€œMileage doesnโ€™t matter that muchโ€

Mileage for car insurance policies matters a lot. If youโ€™re driving 7000 miles or less, then youโ€™re in a very different risk category than if youโ€™re driving 20,000 miles a year or more. It doesnโ€™t always work out as โ€œless is cheaperโ€ though, and donโ€™t be tempted to put in 1000 miles a year if you do 10,000.

11. โ€œYou can drive any car if youโ€™re fully compโ€

This is often a rumour as it used to be a common inclusion on insurance policies. โ€œDrive other car insuranceโ€, or DOC, is more rare these days, and is not included on your policy unless specified otherwise in your policy booklet.

12. โ€œIf you donโ€™t claim, your premium will always go downโ€

Car insurance premiums are mainly driven by market conditions, costs to repair vehicles, how many cars are stolen, and how risky your post code is. This means your insurance prices can rise and fall regularly. Donโ€™t be afraid to shop around.

13. โ€œYou must tell your insurer about every little scratchโ€

Insurers must hear from you about any incidents you may be involved in, but if you accidentally scratch your own car on a hedge, thatโ€™s not something theyโ€™ll normally be able to help you with.

14. โ€œYour insurance covers you to commute to any workplaceโ€

Some insurance policies only cover commuting to one fixed place of work. If you have multiple workplaces, or are self employed, this will have to be discussed with your insurer.

15. โ€œYou donโ€™t need insurance if youโ€™re not drivingโ€

If your car is parked on a public road, then it will need some form of car insurance. If youโ€™re going to SORN your car (Statutary Off Road Notification) then it must be parked on private land too.

16. โ€œYou donโ€™t need to tell your insurance about small modificationsโ€

To cover you fully, itโ€™s worth keep your insurance company in the loop about even small modifications. Not doing this is risky, and can lead to your insurer cancelling your policy, or even refusing to pay out during a claim.

17. โ€œInsurance covers you at the Nurburgringโ€

This is a fun one, and car insurers really do not like the Nurburgring. 99% of the time, there is an exclusion of the Nurburgring Norschleife in your policy booklet. If you crash on the Nurburgring, your insurers may not cover you. Check, double check, and look for track insurance on line. Another great idea to to use one of the many Nurburgring track car rental services, and take out their insurance policies.


Car insurance is a surprisingly complicated topic, so itโ€™s no shame at all if you find it daunting to understand. 99% of the work is keeping your communication between yourself and insurance companies honest, they want to be on your side. If they know youโ€™re willing to work with them, then thereโ€™s nothing to be worried about.

If you want to find out ways to save money on your insurance, stay safer out on the roads, or maybe have more fun on the racetrack, check out our other articles and videos at 222Drive.

Alexander Payne
Alexander Paynehttp://222drive.com
Automotive writer, driver, and content creator also known as "Paynos" on YouTube and social media. Alex has been sharing his passion for Motorsport, Performance Driving, and Teaching with the world for over 10 years. From Karting at the age of 8, all the way through to getting a Racing Licence in 2016, and reaching over 100,000 subscribers on YouTube teaching driving. Alex still has his sights set on becoming the racing diver he's always dreamt of becoming...

Latest Posts